 |
Reviewed by Stephen Byrnes,
ND, RNCP www.PowerHealth.net
Would
you buy a book that was literally set on fire by its critics on a television show
about it in Finland? I would and so should you. The long-awaited English version
of debunker extroidinaire Dr. Uffe Ravnskov's notorious book is now available
from New Trends Publishing.
Ravnskov,
a medical doctor with a PhD in Chemistry, has had over 40 papers and letters published
in peer-reviewed journals criticizing what Dr. George Mann, formerly of Vanderbuilt
University, once called "the greatest scam in the history of medicine": the Lipid
Hypothesis of heart disease, the belief that dietary saturated fats and cholesterol
clog arteries and cause atherosclerosis and heart disease.
If
one thing comes through as you read the book, it is this: Ravnskov has done his
homework. In painstaking detail, he critically analyzes and demolishes the nine
main myths of the Lipid Hypothesis: (1) High-fat foods cause heart disease, (2)
High cholesterol causes heart disease, (3) High fat foods raise blood cholesterol,
(4) Cholesterol blocks arteries, (5) Animal studies prove the diet-heart idea,
(6) Lowering your cholesterol will lengthen your life, (7) Polyunsaturated oils
are good for you, (8) The cholesterol campaign is based on good science, and (9)
All scientists support the diet-heart idea.
Equipped
with a razor-sharp mind, an impressive command of the literature, and a deadly,
needling sarcasm, Ravnskov methodically slaughters the most famous Sacred Cow
of modern medicine and the most profitable Cash Cow for assorted pharmaceutical
companies. Sparing no one, Ravnskov again and again presents the tenets of the
Lipid Hypothesis and the studies which supposedly prove them, and shows how the
studies are flawed or based on manipulated statistics that actually prove nothing.
Ravnskov then answers the objections or rationalizations offered by diet-heart
supporters, desperate to explain away inconsistencies and contradictions in their
own data.
For
example, Ravnskov opens with an analysis of the study that kicked off the Lipid
Hypothesis in the 1950s: Ancel Keys' Six Countries Study (and later, the more
famous Seven Countries Study). As most health professionals know, Keys' study
showed that countries with the highest animal fat intake have the highest rates
of heart disease. Keys' conclusion was that there was a cause and effect relationship
because the country with the lowest animal fat intake (at that time, Japan) had
the lowest rates of heart disease. Sounds convincing, right? Not so, says Dr.
Ravnskov. And in a few pages the reader is informed how Keys hand-picked the countries
he included in his studies, namely, the ones that supported his hypothesis, and
conveniently ignored all of the other countries that didn't.
And
this is just the beginning!
Ravnskov
approaches true brilliance in his review of the studies that supposedly showed
benefit from the current wonder-drugs pushed by the pharmaceutical industry: the
statins. Hailed as miracle substances that "significantly reduce cholesterol and
incidence of heart attacks," Ravnskov shows that these substances are probable
carcinogens (women on the drugs had a much higher incidence of breast cancer)
and that the overall statistical reduction of heart disease in the drug trials
is negligible. Nevertheless, despite the dismal results of the very first trial
(the EXCEL Trial which Ravnskov soberingly describes to the reader), the industry
and its well-funded doctors urge their use, even in people who do not have heart
disease.
Ravnskov
warns: "Because the latent period between exposure to carcinogen and the incidence
of clinical cancer in humans may be 20 years or more, the absence of any controlled
trials of this duration means that we do not know whether statin treatment will
lead to . . . cancer in coming decades. Thus, millions of people are being treated
with medications the ultimate effects of which are not yet known."
If there is one weakness of the book, it is its lack of explanations of what DOES
cause heart disease. Ravnskov comes close to fingering a few factors such as high
stress, excessive polyunsaturated fat intake, trans-fatty acids, and smoking,
but he never offers his own theory as to what causes the Western world's number
one killer.
This
is, however, a minor glitch. Ravnskov has done the world a major service in presenting
his findings. All health professionals need to listen to this scholar and listen
very carefully for the advice offered by the medical establishment for the last
50 years to beat heart disease has failed miserably. It is time to turn away from
cholesterol-lowering drugs that have frightening side effects. It is time to turn
away from tasteless low-fat diets that harm children and deprive people of fat-soluble
vitamins. And it is time to turn away from the junk science that characterizes
the Lipid Hypothesis and its supporters. It is time, instead, to listen to reason
and view all of the evidence against a failed hypothesis and discover the true
and varied risks and causes of heart disease. It is time to listen to Uffe Ravnskov. |